Comments on: Let’s try this again… http://www.theidolguy.com/season-eight/lets-try-this-again/ American Idol news and commentary: Cutting through the cow manure Fri, 23 Sep 2011 15:36:55 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: The Idol Guy http://www.theidolguy.com/season-eight/lets-try-this-again/comment-page-1/#comment-45 The Idol Guy Sat, 21 Mar 2009 12:55:54 +0000 http://www.theidolguy.com/season-eight/lets-try-this-again/#comment-45 I addressed this in the proper thread, but: - Maybe, but it's worth noting that Fantasia spent time in a bottom group - the last winner to do so. She won, yes, but it wasn't as smooth a ride as winners of late have had. As for the Martina/Melinda mixup; it's fixed. I addressed this in the proper thread, but:

- Maybe, but it’s worth noting that Fantasia spent time in a bottom group – the last winner to do so. She won, yes, but it wasn’t as smooth a ride as winners of late have had.

As for the Martina/Melinda mixup; it’s fixed.

]]> By: julika http://www.theidolguy.com/season-eight/lets-try-this-again/comment-page-1/#comment-42 julika Sat, 21 Mar 2009 02:51:21 +0000 http://www.theidolguy.com/season-eight/lets-try-this-again/#comment-42 Fantasia and Diana DeGarmo were in the same group (group #1) their season. And I'd say Fantasia did pretty well, even though she was in the first group. Jennifer Hudson was also in that group, and I honestly think one of the reasons she went out so early was that the other two were in the same group, and they kind of grabbed all the attention (or pimping) from the get-go. That year there were four groups, so it should've been even easier to forget group #1 if your theory held. Which it pretty much doesn't, considering both the winner and the runner-up were in that group. And it's Martina McBride, not Melinda. Fantasia and Diana DeGarmo were in the same group (group #1) their season. And I’d say Fantasia did pretty well, even though she was in the first group. Jennifer Hudson was also in that group, and I honestly think one of the reasons she went out so early was that the other two were in the same group, and they kind of grabbed all the attention (or pimping) from the get-go. That year there were four groups, so it should’ve been even easier to forget group #1 if your theory held. Which it pretty much doesn’t, considering both the winner and the runner-up were in that group.

And it’s Martina McBride, not Melinda.

]]>